The 10 Best Snapped: Women Who Murder Podcast Episodes
In this audio-only version of the beloved and long-running true crime TV show Snapped: Women Who Murder, you’ll hear the little-known stories of many fascinating female killers. Whether they were motivated by greed, infidelity, jealousy, or something else entirely, Snapped gives a detailed look into their lives and the investigations into their crimes. The original Snapped TV show first aired in 2004 on the Oxygen network, and has since become their longest-running original series, with 28 seasons. In the podcast version of the show, you’ll hear directly from interviewees who experienced the case first hand, including detectives, lawyers, friends, family members, and sometimes even the killer themselves. Tying it all together is voice-over narration from host Jody Flader, who expertly guides listeners through these twisted true crime tales. So buckle up and check out these best Snapped episodes, curated with recommendations from Podyssey’s community of true crime lovers.
Last Updated: Jan 14th, 2023
1) Kathleen Dorsett
On August 16, 2010, Stephen Moore was dropping off his toddler at his ex-wife’s parents’ home in New Jersey. When he failed to show up for work later that day he was reported missing, and two days later his body was found — on fire — in his mother’s car. When Stephen’s ex-wife, 36-year-old elementary school teacher Kathleen Dorsett, was informed of her ex-husband’s death, she was strangely unaffected. As detectives dug into the case, however, they realized that not all was well in their relationship, and that Kathleen and her parents were planning to move her and the couple’s toddler to Florida. The story of what really happened to Stephen — and how police eventually arrested the multiple poeple responsible for his murder — is a sordid true crime story of a very nefarious family, making it one of the best episodes of Snapped: Women Who Murder.
2) Carol Carlson
When police arrived to investigate the murder of Lisa Carlson, they found a very bizarre crime scene. The mother of twins was lying down on the couch, pornography playing on the TV, and a vibrator beside her. The room was a mess — a robbery gone wrong? But no real valuables had been taken. Investigators quickly determined that the crime scene had been poorly staged, indicating that Lisa had likely known her killer. Detectives zeroed in on Lisa’s estranged husband, Dan, whom she had been planning on leaving that very day. But they were also suspicious of Dan’s mother, who ruled the family with an iron fist. What really happened that day? Listen to this best Snapped episode to find out.
3) Cindy Reese
On a February night in 2015, Cindy Reese returned home from the local Piggly Wiggly to find the front room in disarray. She called 911, thinking people had broken into the house. When police arrived, they found Cindy’s Husband, Michael Reese, shot execution style. When questioned about the murder, Cindy said she had seen a suspicious man in a dark hoodie nearby, and that there had been construction in and out of the house. But as police worked to find the killer, a scandal was revealed at the church where Cindy and Michael were devout parishioners: Cindy was having an affair with the pastor. This captivating best episode is all about a close-knit church community gone wrong, and is definitely a must-listen for any Snapped fans.
4) Courtney Schulhoff
In 2004, Courtney Schulhoff confessed to murdering her father when she was 16. Her dad had forbidden her to see her boyfriend, spurring the two lovers to seek revenge.
AUDIO REMOVED: The podcast creator has removed the audio for this episode.5) Kelly Ryan
A look at how Kelly Ryan snapped, allegedly murdering her assistant and husband's supposed lover Melissa James, and disposing of her body in a burning car.
AUDIO REMOVED: The podcast creator has removed the audio for this episode.6) Sarah Jo Pender
Convicted along with her former boyfriend of the cold-blooded murder of their two roommates in 2000, Sarah Jo Pender was sentenced to 110 years in prison.
7) Betty Neumar
The cold-case shooting of a Norwood, North Carolina man leaves his family shattered and without answers. After two decades pass the investigation resumes only to uncover mysterious deaths spanning a h...Show More
8) Notorious: Hollywood Ripper
A killer escapes his past and finds a new hunting ground in a city of dreamers. In 2019, after a decades long hunt across four police departments, Michael Gargiulo, now known as The Hollywood Ripper, ...Show More
9) Donna Blanton
The death of a state trooper leads to an all-out hunt for his killer, but the evidence points to his new wife and a big secret.
10) Brittany Norwood
A look at the brutal murder of Jayna Murray, who was stabbed over 300 times by Brittany Norwood in a yoga store. What caused her violent colleague to snap?