The 10 Best My Brother My Brother and Me Episodes
Are you in need of brotherly advice? Well, the McElroy brothers aren’t experts, and their advice shouldn’t be followed, but if you’re looking for a good comedy podcast you’ll love the energy these brothers bring to the studio! From their obsession with Jimmy Buffet and Margaritaville, endless inside jokes (Amelie!), and early Yahoo! Answers days, the MBMBAM podcast will make you feel like part of the family. For the best My Brother My Brother and Me episodes, start with this list of recommendations from Podyssey users and get bingeing!
Last Updated: Aug 26th, 2021
1) MBMBaM 400: The Escape to Margaritaville Red Carpet Extravaganza
This is the big special quadricentennial MBMBaM episode where the McElroy brothers hit the red carpet of the opening of Broadway production “Escape to Margaritaville” by Jimmy Buffett. Hear them freak out and freeze up in their attempts to ask celebrities for random advice. This hysterical episode will have you bite your nails in nervousness for the brothers while you laugh out loud at the same time. Hamilton star and the McElory’s good friend Lin-Manuel Miranda also makes a guest appearance to make this best MBMBaM episode even better!
2) MBMBaM 389: Horsebonology
The MBMBaM brothers give totally unqualified advice to their listeners about “sweat dresses” and “dude robes”. They also spend some time pondering a mind-twisting ghostly paradox. You’ll also get a good dose of farm wisdom like the philosophy of egg cracking and a biological exploration of whether horse legs are actually fingers. With cold medicine-incited digressions, this is one of the funniest MBMBaM episodes that will give your brian a good workout too.
3) MBMBaM 370: Dax Don't Care
The McElroys don’t disappoint when they start off a bang on the obscure origins of the word “ejaculation”. They not-so-quickly move on to review their yearly experience at Margaritaville and various odd themed restaurants. Hear them answer a listener's question about a hilarious dilemma of a potential bike thief. They brothers also discuss other important topics like how to win a celebrity Twitter fight and whether friendships should come with a contract. There’s definitely lots of great unqualified and tongue-in-the-cheek advice in this top MBMBaM episode.
4) MBMBaM 513: Mother Cruncher
In which we make an unprecedented mid-year swap-eroonie, and then do our due diligence to inform the federal government about the change. We THINK we got our message through, but there’s no way to kno...Show More
5) MBMBaM 492: The Naming of 2020
It has arrived. Our annual opportunity to place a steady hand upon the rudder of the new year is here, and boy howdy, it’s a big one. Twenty-Twenty?! It’s the same thing twice! Is that anything? Pleas...Show More
6) MBMBaM 527: HORSEWAR
When we were doing the whole big war, and needed sentient, quadrupedal transportation all hither and yon, they were there for us. Now, in their hour of conflict, it is time for us to return the favor....Show More
7) MBMBaM 499: Right Down the Middle
THIS IS A NORMAL EPISODE. Please do not come into this one thinking we’re doing some kind of pre-500 celebration, or something. It’s NORMAL. There is NOTHING that sets it apart from all the other epis...Show More
8) MBMBaM 498: Single Sleeved Sweater
The energy in this one … is difficult to describe. Was it a result of us recording back-to-back episodes during a busy pre-travel prep session? Yes. Was it also the result of a soft and extremely haun...Show More
9) MBMBaM 490: Ewdaddy
What is … flavor? What defines the essence of an object’s true, unambiguous taste? Is flavor, perhaps, in the tongue of the food-haver? Also, mind if we sprinkle a little bit of dirt on this lasagna? ...Show More
10) MBMBaM 479: Face 2 Face: A Spectral, Horny Build-A-Bear
This live show, from our recent tour stop in Pittsburgh, will probably go down in history as “the one where we unknowingly distributed 100 KFC Doughnut Chicken Sandwiches to our audience, who, for som...Show More
