10 Podcasts like My Favorite Murder
Calling all murderinos! If you’ve binged MFM and are looking to fill the Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark shaped hole in your heart, make sure to check out these podcasts similar to My Favorite Murder, curated with the help of Podyssey’s community of true crime lovers.
Last Updated: Aug 3rd, 2021
1. Morbid
It’s a lighthearted nightmare in here, weirdos! Morbid is a true crime, creepy history and all things spooky podcast hosted by an autopsy technician and a hairstylist. Join us for a heavy dose of research with a dash of comedy thrown in for flavor....Show More
Most Recommended Episode
Episode 122: The West Memphis Three Part 1
59:17 | Mar 2nd, 2020
2 RECOMMENDATIONS
This is going to be a doozy of a series, weirdos. Tonight, we start our deep coverage of the West Memphis Three case. Part 1 will cover the tragic murders of 8 year olds Christopher Byers. Michael Moo...Show More
2. And That's Why We Drink
Murder and the paranormal finally meet! Grab your wine and milkshakes and join us every Sunday for some chilling ghost stories and downright terrifying true crime stories. The world's a scary place. And that's why we drink!
Most Recommended Episode
E1 Francis Ford “Cupola” and the Off-Brand Kool-Aid
1:07:39 | Feb 9th, 2017
4 RECOMMENDATIONS
Get your wine and milkshakes ready - it’s time for the first episode of And That’s Why We Drink! Em tells Christine all about one of the most haunted places in America, the Winchester Mystery House....Show More
3. Criminalia
Humans have always committed crimes. What can we learn from the criminals and crimes of the past, and have humans gotten better or worse over time?
Most Recommended Episode
The Pseudo-Nero: When One Nero Isn't Enough
28:30 | Aug 17th, 2021
1 RECOMMENDATION
Nero wasn't always described as a tyrant – he was a teenager, considered handsome and sensitive. Despite his reign becaming violent, three different pretended to be him.
4. Sinisterhood
Dallas based comedians and friends, Christie Wallace and Heather McKinney, focus on a different true crime, cult, or creepy topic each week "and chat all things sinister in this funny and well-researched podcast." (Marie Claire, 2020)
Most Recommended Episode
1:18:02 | Mar 11th, 2020
1 RECOMMENDATION
Two perfect twin daughters, born to excited and happy parents. But as they grew, their behavior was cause for concern. What started as shy silence and a fun secret language between sisters, embroiled ...Show More
5. Small Town Murder
Two comedians look at a small town, what makes it tick, and a murder that took place there. In depth research, horrible tragedy, and the hosts' comedic spin on the whole thing. New episodes every Thursday!!
Most Recommended Episode
#032 - Broken Bones & Brutal Murder in Baraboo, Wisconsin
1:12:50 | Aug 24th, 2017
1 RECOMMENDATION
This week, we look at the circus loving town of Baraboo, Wisconsin, where one person's acts of brutality were like nothing anyone had ever seen. One young man's desire to live was the only thing that...Show More
AUDIO REMOVED: The podcast creator has removed the audio for this episode.6. Wine & Crime
Wine & Crime is a true crime / comedy podcast. Join three friends as they chug wine, chat true crime, and unleash their worst Minnesotan accents!
Most Recommended Episode
1:41:41 | Feb 2nd, 2017
2 RECOMMENDATIONS
The gals dive right in with a classic taboo, discussing the perks and pitfalls of sex with a corpse. Criminal cases include Jeffrey Dahmer, Anatoly Moskvin, Edmund Kemper III, and Bryan Hathaway. This...Show More
7. Last Podcast On The Left
The Last Podcast On The Left covers all the horrors our world has to offer both imagined and real, from demons and slashers to cults and serial killers, The Last Podcast is guaranteed to satisfy your blood lust.
Most Recommended Episode
1:04:28 | Feb 17th, 2015
5 RECOMMENDATIONS
In honor of the 20th anniversary of the infamous murders, we cover everyone's favorite hidden camera prankster O.J. Simpson as he jukes and jives his way through the heavy hitting Trial of the Century...Show More
8. Crimes and Consequences
Listen to the gripping details of the world's most brutal murders presented to you by two attorneys who rely on their sarcasm and wit to plow through the horrors of the crimes. Court and police records are heavily relied on to ensure the accuracy of ...Show More
Most Recommended Episode
51:48 | Feb 22nd, 2021
1 RECOMMENDATION
In 1996, Rachel Timmerman filed rape charges against a monster named Marvin Gabrion. As the trial approached, witnesses came up missing. Then Rachel disappeared along with her baby after going out o...Show More
9. Rotten Mango
Rotten but still a little sweet! Rotten Mango is a true crime + all things spooky podcast. We love doing deep dives into the darkest crimes and we tend to not leave out any details - which can get a little rotten at times. If you want deep dives in t...Show More
Most Recommended Episode
#2- 44 Days Of Hell – The Murder of Junko Furuta
1:24:16 | Jun 17th, 2020
2 RECOMMENDATIONS
The darkest case I have ever covered 44 days of the sickest torture... there's burning alive... and fireworks involved? It get's really dark. To learn more about listener data and our privacy pra...Show More
10. Dark Poutine - True Crime and Dark History
True crime, legends, folklore, dark history and other creepy topics from the perspective of real live Canadians.
Most Recommended Episode
The Tragic Death of Elisa Lam (BC)
56:52 | Jul 20th, 2018
2 RECOMMENDATIONS
Episode 036: Elisa Lam, a University student from Vancouver, BC was on a solo trip in California in January of 2013. When she disappeared, foul play was suspected. However, when she was found deceased...Show More