The 8 Best Crime Junkie Episodes of All Time

1) MURDERED: Laci Peterson

In this two-part series, Ashley and Brit dive deep into the horrific murder of Laci Peterson and her unborn son. This case, which was highly publicized in 2002 when Laci went missing, is viewed by many to be open and shut: Laci’s husband Scott Peterson was convicted and sentenced to death. But Scott and his family have maintained his innocence. So, was he really responsible? Ashley’s thorough analysis of this case will likely make this one of your favorite Crime Junkie episodes ever.

2) ADNAN: What Serial Didn’t Tell You

If you’re looking for podcasts like Serial, you need to listen to this Crime Junkie episode, which concisely sums up the details of Adnan Syed’s case that Serial didn’t cover. When it came out in 2018, this episode caused quite a stir in the true crime community, helping launch the Crime Junkie podcast to the top of the charts — even Georgia Hardstark from My Favourite Murder shared her love for this episode.

3) MISSING: Bryce Laspisa

Many crime junkies say this episode is the one they still think about every single day. Bryce disappeared just two weeks after returning to university in 2013. His behaviour had become strange and, on the day of his disappearance, he spent almost 13 hours just sitting in his car in a small town, refusing to explain to anyone what was going on. It’s one of those missing person’s cases that just feel intensely eerie — like something is deeply wrong but you’re not sure exactly what. If you like unsolved mysteries, this is a strange one you’ll want to sink your teeth into.

4) WANTED: Killer on the High Bridge

This episode about the murder of two teen girls hits home for the Crime Junkie hosts as it takes place very close to where they grew up in Indiana. It’s an unsolved case, but there are recordings of the suspect taken on one of the victim’s phones that police hope will lead to his arrest. Still, no one has been able to identify him. This is one of those mysteries that plagues the true crime community to this day. Make sure to listen to this episode, and then the update for more information.

5) SERIAL KILLER: Israel Keyes

The story of Israel Keyes is the most haunting kind of serial killer case — a brutal rapist and murderer who could have easily gone uncaught for his entire life. He was a normal-looking guy who perfectly disguised his inner evil, killing people across the US for years undetected. With no connection to his victims, and meticulously planned out “murder trips” complete with “kill kits” hidden in cities across the country, this killer’s M.O. will leave you with chills.

6) MURDERED: The Powell Family

This tragic family annihilation case is told by host Brit Prawat, and it’s the kind of episode that is bound to stick with you. It’s full of strange family dynamics, a terrifying father figure, and 911 calls that will leave you shocked and infuriated. Make sure to listen to the end for the terrible, gut-wrenching twist.

7) SERIAL KILLER: L.I.S.K.

When four escorts’ bodies are found on a beach on Long Island, the police realize they’re looking for a serial killer who uses Craigslist to find his victims. Ashley Flowers recounts this creepy, convoluted story in detail, taking the listener through the disturbing moments in this interesting unsolved case. If you’re looking for the best Crime Junkie serial killer episodes, make sure to listen to this one.

8) BWBRSA: Operation Fireball

When a young woman connects with a man on Plenty of Fish, he tells her to meet him at a nearby restaurant. But when he texts her saying that he’s running late, he suggests that she order them two shots of Fireball. What happens next makes this a unique Crime Junkie episode — it’s not about a missing person or a serial killer, but it’s a strange near-miss story that will leave you feeling incredibly uneasy. We won’t spoil it, but this episode is a must-listen.